Skip to Main content
  • Papa's Pizza Oven

Legacy Sports Bar & Papa's Pizza Oven Legacy Sports Bar & Papa's Pizza Oven

1537 Union Road, West Seneca, NY
Change location
‌
‌
Pizza
Wings & Fingers
Combos & Specials
Appetizers
Sandwiches Subs & Wraps
Beverages (NA)
Dips & Extras
Desserts

Featured Items

  • Large Pizza (BYO)

    $23.99
  • 50 Bone-In Wings

    No blue Cheese Included today (anniversary celebration pricing!)
    $64.00
  • 20 Bone-In Wings

    Blue Cheese Included
    $29.50

Pizza

Pizza

  • Quarter Pizza (BYO)

    $8.99
  • Half Pizza (BYO)

    $13.99
  • Large Pizza (BYO)

    $23.99
  • Sheet Pizza (BYO)

    2 larges (32 squares)
    $43.99
  • Slice of Pizza

    $4.99

Quarter Specialty

  • Buffalo Chicken Finger (Quarter)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), with a mozzarella finish
    $12.50
  • Papa’s White, Bacon (Quarter)

    Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with a mozzarella finish.
    $12.50
  • Papa’s White, Sausage (Quarter)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, spinach, tomatoes, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.
    $12.25
  • Original White (Quarter)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with tomatoes, onions, Romano and a mozzarella finish
    $11.75
  • Steak & 5 Cheese (Quarter)

    Garlic butter base, topped with a pound of steak, with onions, sweet & banana peppers, finished with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella, and cheddar. Mushrooms optional.
    $12.50
  • Stinger (Quarter)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), topped with mozzarella
    $13.50
  • Steak in the Grass (Quarter)

    Garlic butter base, topped with spinach and a pound of steak, with a mozzarella finish
    $12.50
  • Veggie (Quarter)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), and choice of 3 - tomatoes, spinach, hot or sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black or green olives
    $12.25
  • Double Cheese Double Pep (Quarter)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), topped with 26 oz of cheese and 12 oz of fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni
    $12.25
  • 5 Cheese Garlic (Quarter)

    Garlic butter base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
    $11.75
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch (Quarter)

    $12.50

Half Specialty

  • Buffalo Chicken Finger (Half)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), with a mozzarella finish
    $19.99
  • Papa’s White, Bacon (Half)

    Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with a mozzarella finish.
    $19.99
  • Papa’s White, Sausage (Half)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, spinach, tomatoes, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.
    $19.99
  • Original White (Half)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with tomatoes, onions, Romano and a mozzarella finish
    $16.75
  • Steak & 5 Cheese (Half)

    Garlic butter base, topped with a pound of steak, with onions, sweet & banana peppers, finished with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella, and cheddar. Mushrooms optional.
    $20.75
  • Stinger (Half)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), topped with mozzarella
    $21.75
  • Steak in the Grass (Half)

    Garlic butter base, topped with spinach and a pound of steak, with a mozzarella finish
    $20.75
  • Veggie (Half)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), and choice of 3 - tomatoes, spinach, hot or sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black or green olives
    $20.75
  • Double Cheese Double Pep (Half)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), topped with 26 oz of cheese and 12 oz of fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni
    $19.99
  • 5 Cheese Garlic (Half)

    Garlic butter base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
    $16.75
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch (Half)

    $19.99

Large Specialty

  • Buffalo Chicken Finger (Large)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), with a mozzarella finish
    $33.50
  • Papa’s White, Bacon (Large)

    Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with a mozzarella finish.
    $33.50
  • Papa’s White, Sausage (Large)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, spinach, tomatoes, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.
    $33.50
  • Original White (Large)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with tomatoes, onions, Romano and a mozzarella finish
    $28.50
  • Steak & 5 Cheese (Large)

    Garlic butter base, topped with a pound of steak, with onions, sweet & banana peppers, finished with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella, and cheddar. Mushrooms optional.
    $34.75
  • Stinger (Large)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), topped with mozzarella
    $39.50
  • Steak in the Grass (Large)

    Garlic butter base, topped with spinach and a pound of steak, with a mozzarella finish
    $34.75
  • Veggie (Large)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), and choice of 3 - tomatoes, spinach, hot or sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black or green olives
    $33.50
  • Double Cheese Double Pep (Large)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), topped with 26 oz of cheese and 12 oz of fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni
    $33.50
  • 5 Cheese Garlic (Large)

    Garlic butter base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
    $28.50
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch (Large)

    $33.50

Sheet Specialty

  • Buffalo Chicken Finger (Sheet)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, with over a pound of chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), with a mozzarella finish
    $59.50
  • Papa’s White, Bacon (Sheet)

    Ranch base, over a pound of chicken fingers, bacon, with a mozzarella finish.
    $59.50
  • Papa’s White, Sausage (Sheet)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with onions, spinach, tomatoes, and your choice of bacon or Italian sausage. Romano, with a mozzarella finish.
    $59.50
  • Original White (Sheet)

    Homemade white sauce (olive oil base), topped with tomatoes, onions, Romano and a mozzarella finish
    $49.50
  • Steak & 5 Cheese (Sheet)

    Garlic butter base, topped with a pound of steak, with onions, sweet & banana peppers, finished with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella, and cheddar. Mushrooms optional.
    $62.50
  • Stinger (Sheet)

    Homemade blue cheese and medium sauce base, 1.5 pounds of steak and chicken fingers (sauced any way you like, medium by default), topped with mozzarella
    $67.50
  • Steak in the Grass (Sheet)

    Garlic butter base, topped with spinach and a pound of steak, with a mozzarella finish
    $62.50
  • Veggie (Sheet)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), and choice of 3 - tomatoes, spinach, hot or sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions, and black or green olives
    $59.50
  • Double Cheese Double Pep (Sheet)

    Red sauce base (Regular or Sweet), topped with 26 oz of cheese and 12 oz of fresh cut aged margherita pepperoni
    $59.50
  • 5 Cheese Garlic (Sheet)

    Garlic butter base, topped with Romano, American, Swiss, mozzarella and cheddar cheese.
    $44.50
  • Chicken Bacon Ranch (Sheet)

    $59.50

Wings & Fingers

  • 10 Bone-In Wings

    Blue Cheese Included
    $16.50
  • 20 Bone-In Wings

    Blue Cheese Included
    $29.50
  • 30 Bone-In Wings

    Blue Cheese Included
    $38.50
  • 50 Bone-In Wings

    No blue Cheese Included today (anniversary celebration pricing!)
    $64.00
  • 10 Boneless Wings + Fries

    $16.50
  • 20 Boneless Wings + Fries

    $29.50
  • 30 Boneless Wings + Fries

    $38.50
  • 50 Boneless Wings + Fries

    $64.00
  • 5 Fingers + Fries

    $18.75
  • 10 Fingers + Fries

    $32.99
  • 20 Fingers + Fries

    $54.99

Combos & Specials

Pizza Combos & Specials

  • Quarter Pizza + 10 Wings

    $20.74
  • Half Pizza + 10 Wings

    $26.74
  • Large Pizza + 20 Wings

    $45.99
  • Sheet Pizza + 50 Wings

    $87.99
  • Quarter Pizza + 10 Boneless Wings & Fries

    $20.74
  • Half Pizza + 10 Boneless Wings & Fries

    $26.74
  • Large Pizza + 20 Boneless Wings & Fries

    $45.99
  • Sheet Pizza + 50 Boneless Wings & Fries

    $87.99
  • 2 Slice

    $10.00

Lunch Specials: Non-sub

  • 2-Slice and Soft Drink

    $9.99
  • Kids Buffet

    $7.99

Appetizers

  • French Fries

    $6.99
  • Loaded Tater Tots

    topped w/ beer cheese, bacon, and sour cream
    $12.99
  • Mozzarella Sticks

    $6.95
  • Bread Sticks

    $4.99
  • Jalapeño Poppers

    $8.99
  • Onion Rings

    $7.99
  • Pretzel Sticks

    w/ a beer cheese sauce
    $10.99
  • Pizza Logs

    $10.99
  • Giant Nachos

    House made chips topped with beer cheese, taco meat, shredded cheese, tomatoes, jalapenos, & sour cream
    $14.99
  • App Combo Platter

    2 pizza logs, 2 chicken fingers, 3 mozzarella sticks, and fries or onion rings
    $18.99

Sandwiches Subs & Wraps

Burgers & Sandwiches (non-subs)

  • Classic Burger

    $13.99
  • Mushroom Swiss Burger

    $16.99
  • Hickory Burger

    $16.99
  • Nashville Crispy Chicken Sandwich

    Crispy Chicken Sandwich with your choice of: Nashville Hot, BBQ, or Cajun
    $13.99
  • Beef on Weck

    $15.99
  • Weck + Wings Combo

    $19.99
  • Beef Burrito

    $12.99

Full Subs & Wraps

  • Assorted Cold Sub

    $12.99
  • Ham Sub

    $12.99
  • Turkey Sub

    $12.99
  • Salami Sub

    $12.99
  • Turkey Bacon Sub

    $14.99
  • Chicken Finger Sub

    $13.99
  • Steak Hoagie Sub

    $15.99
  • Stinger Sub

    $16.99
  • BLT Sub

    $15.99

1/2 Subs & Wraps

  • 1/2 Assorted Cold Sub

    $8.99
  • 1/2 Ham Sub

    $8.99
  • 1/2 Salami Sub

    $8.99
  • 1/2 Turkey Sub

    $8.99
  • 1/2 Chicken Finger Sub

    $9.99
  • 1/2 Steak Hoagie Sub

    $11.99
  • 1/2 Stinger Sub

    $12.99
  • 1/2 Turkey Bacon Sub

    $10.99
  • 1/2 BLT Sub

    $11.99

Beverages (NA)

Fountain Drinks

  • Coke

    $3.99
  • Diet Coke

    $3.99
  • Sprite

    $3.99
  • Ginger Ale

    $3.99
  • Loganberry

    $3.99
  • Mr. Pibb

    $3.99
  • Root Beer

    $3.99
  • Bar Lemonade

    $3.99
  • Sweet Tea

    $3.99
  • Soda Water

    $3.99
  • Peace Tea Peach

    $3.99

Bottled Soda

  • BTL Coke

    $2.99
  • BTL Diet Coke

    $2.99
  • BTL Coke Zero

    $2.99
  • BTL Coke Cherry

    $2.99
  • BTL Coke Vanilla

    $2.99
  • BTL Coke Orange Cream Zero

    $2.99
  • BTL Sprite

    $2.99
  • BTL Sprite Cherry

    $2.99
  • BTL Sprite Winter Cranberry

    $2.99
  • BTL Ginger Ale

    $2.99
  • BTL Ginger Ale Fruit Splash

    $2.99
  • BTL Fanta Orange

    $2.99
  • BTL Fresca

    $2.99
  • BTL Root Beer

    $2.99
  • BTL Loganberry

    $2.99
  • BTL Dasani Water

    $2.99
  • BTL Smart Water

    $2.99
  • BTL Sweet Tea

    $2.99
  • BTL Unsweet Tea

    $2.99

Sports Drinks

  • Powerade (Blue)

    $2.99
  • Powerade (Red)

    $2.99
  • Powerade (Grape)

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water XXX

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Dragon Fruit

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Blue Razz Limeade

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Strawberry Lemonade (0 Sugar)

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Tropical Citrus (Energy)

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Tropical Mango

    $2.99
  • Vitamin Water Pineapple Passion (0 Sugar)

    $2.99

2-Liters

  • Coke 2L

    $4.25
  • Diet Coke 2L

    $4.25
  • Coke Zero 2L

    $4.25
  • Coke Cherry 2L

    $4.25
  • Sprite 2L

    $4.25
  • Fanta Orange 2L

    $4.25
  • Ginger Ale 2L

    $4.25
  • Ginger Ale Cranberry 2L

    $4.25
  • Ginger Ale Fruit Splash 2L

    $4.25
  • Loganberry 2L

    $4.25

Glass Bottles

  • Coke (Glass Bottle)

    $3.49
  • Sprite (Glass Bottle)

    $3.49
  • Fanta Orange (Glass Bottle)

    $3.49

Dips & Extras

  • Blue Cheese (3.25 oz)

    $1.99
  • Blue Cheese (12 oz)

    $5.99
  • Regular Sauce (3.25 oz)

    $1.00
  • Sweet Sauce (3.25 oz)

    $1.00
  • Mixed Sauce (3.25 oz)

    $1.00

Desserts

  • Specialty Brownie

    OUT OF STOCK
    $6.99
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie (2)

    $2.00
  • cake

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.99
  • choc chip\m&m cookies (3)

    $3.00
  • plain brownie

    OUT OF STOCK
    $5.99

Stinger Sub

$16.99

Customize your item

Sub Bread

Required
Select 1

Chicken Finger Sauce (mix up to 3)

Required
Select 1 to 3

Chicken Finger/Stinger Basic

Optional

Premium Hot Sub Mods

Optional
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Papa's Pizza Oven Locations

Alden

(716) 902-4128
13268 Broadway Street, Alden, NY 14004

Legacy Sports Bar & Papa's Pizza Oven

(716) 671-8555
1537 Union Road, West Seneca, NY 14224

Papa's Pizza Amherst

(716) 525-1234
2675 Niagara Falls Boulevard, Amherst, NY 14228

Papa's Pizza Buffalo

(716) 826-2628
1177 Abbott Road, Buffalo, NY 14220

Papa's Pizza Hamburg

(716) 646-6655
507 Sunset Drive, Hamburg, NY 14075

Papa's Pizza Oven Cheektowaga

(716) 901-7800
2990 Union Road, Cheektowaga, NY 14227

Papa's Pizza Oven Lancaster

(716) 288-9444
155 Lake Avenue, Lancaster, NY 14086
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement